GLM47 Humble (seed 6) vs Gem3F Tinker (seed 11)
4 major, 1 moderate, 14 minor, 2 questionable blunders
Season 1
/ 463
Stack
Game Log
llmGLM47 Humble game_start
llmGem3F Tinker game_start
gameGem3F Tinker's library is shuffled
gameGLM47 Humble's library is shuffled
Gem3F TinkermcpMulligan
raw
choose_action(choice=p2)
{
  "action_pending": true,
  "action_type": "GAME_ASK",
  "message": "Mulligan down to 6 cards?",
  "response_type": "boolean",
  "respond_with": "choice=yes or choice=no",
  "context": "T1 ()",
  "board": [
    {
      "hand_size": 7,
      "is_active": false,
      "is_you": true,
      "name": "Gem3F Tinker",
      "library_size": 33,
      "life": 20,
      "hand": [
        {
          "name": "Island",
          "is_land": true,
          "rules": [
            "{T}: Add {U}."
          ],
          "id": "p10"
        },
        {
          "mana_cost": "{2}{U}",
          "name": "Lookout's Dispersal",
          "rules": [
            "This spell costs {1} less to cast if you control a Pirate.",
            "Counter target spell unless its controller pays {4}."
          ],
          "id": "p11"
        },
        {
          "mana_cost": "{2}{U}",
          "name": "Merrow Reejerey",
          "rules": [
            "Other Merfolk creatures you control get +1/+1.",
            "Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, you may tap or untap target permanent."
          ],
          "power": "2",
          "id": "p12",
          "toughness": "2"
        },
        {
          "mana_cost": "{2}{U}",
          "name": "Mirror Image",
          "rules": [
            "You may have {this} enter as a copy of a creature you control."
          ],
          "power": "0",
          "id": "p13",
          "toughness": "0"
        },
        {
          "mana_cost": "{2}{U}{U}",
          "name": "Seafloor Oracle",
          "rules": [
            "Whenever a Merfolk you control deals combat damage to a player, draw a card."
          ],
          "power": "2",
          "id": "p14",
          "toughness": "3"
        },
        {
          "mana_cost": "{3}{U}",
          "name": "Soul Read",
          "rules": [
            "Choose one —: &bull Counter target spell unless its controller pays {4}.: &bull Draw two cards.: "
          ],
          "id": "p15"
        },
        {
          "mana_cost": "{1}",
          "name": "Universal Automaton",
          "rules": [
            "Changeling (This card is every creature type.)"
          ],
          "power": "1",
          "id": "p16",
          "toughness": "1"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "hand_size": 7,
      "is_active": false,
      "is_you": false,
      "name": "GLM47 Humble",
      "library_size": 33,
      "life": 20
    }
  ],
  "board_cursor": 2,
  "your_hand": [
    {
      "name": "Island",
      "is_land": true,
      "rules": [
        "{T}: Add {U}."
      ]
    },
    {
      "mana_cost": "{2}{U}",
      "name": "Lookout's Dispersal",
      "rules": [
        "This spell costs {1} less to cast if you control a Pirate.",
        "Counter target spell unless its controller pays {4}."
      ]
    },
    {
      "mana_cost": "{2}{U}",
      "name": "Merrow Reejerey",
      "rules": [
        "Other Merfolk creatures you control get +1/+1.",
        "Whenever you cast a Merfolk spell, you may tap or untap target permanent."
      ],
      "power": "2",
      "toughness": "2"
    },
    {
      "mana_cost": "{2}{U}",
      "name": "Mirror Image",
      "rules": [
        "You may have {this} enter as a copy of a creature you control."
      ],
      "power": "0",
      "toughness": "0"
    },
    {
      "mana_cost": "{2}{U}{U}",
      "name": "Seafloor Oracle",
      "rules": [
        "Whenever a Merfolk you control deals combat damage to a player, draw a card."
      ],
      "power": "2",
      "toughness": "3"
    },
    {
      "mana_cost": "{3}{U}",
      "name": "Soul Read",
      "rules": [
        "Choose one —: &bull Counter target spell unless its controller pays {4}.: &bull Draw two cards.: "
      ]
    },
    {
      "mana_cost": "{1}",
      "name": "Universal Automaton",
      "rules": [
        "Changeling (This card is every creature type.)"
      ],
      "power": "1",
      "toughness": "1"
    }
  ],
  "game_seq": 5,
  "action_taken": "selected_target_0",
  "success": true
}
questionable
Bottoming an Island when the hand has expensive spells (Seafloor Oracle at 2UU, Merrow Reejerey at 2U) means keeping onl…
Bottoming an Island when the hand has expensive spells (Seafloor Oracle at 2UU, Merrow Reejerey at 2U) means keeping only 3 lands. Getting stuck on 3 lands would strand the 4-mana Oracle. Soul Read competes with Oracle at 4 mana and is less impactful for the Merfolk synergy gameplan.
Analysis
Action taken: Bottomed an Island, keeping 3 lands
Better line: Bottom Soul Read instead - it's the most expendable card competing at the same mana cost as Seafloor Oracle, and Lookout's Dispersal already provides interaction. Keeping 4 lands ensures casting Oracle on curve.